Suffolk County swung 17 points toward Hochul. The sandbar barely moved — because it was already deep blue. But walk east from Ocean Beach to Cherry Grove and the same island splits from 2-to-1 to 10-to-1.
Tap a precinct. Fire Island is split into two pure barrier-island Election Districts (one in each town) plus one district that mixes the eastern beach with a slice of mainland Patchogue (hatched).
Every race on the ballot, precinct by precinct. Blue = Democratic candidate (Dem + WFP lines combined). Red = Republican candidate (Rep + Conservative + other lines combined).
Kismet · Saltaire · Fair Harbor · Dunewood · Ocean Beach · Seaview · Ocean Bay Park · Point O’Woods
2022 Governor here: Hochul 283, Zeldin 157
Cherry Grove · Fire Island Pines · Water Island
2022 Governor here: Hochul 124, Zeldin 19
Davis Park · Watch Hill + a mainland slice of Patchogue
2022 Governor here: Hochul 206, Zeldin 373
Off-season turnout is tiny: 330 governor votes on the barrier island in 2026 vs. 583 in 2022 — most summer residents vote at their primary homes in NYC or elsewhere.
Sources & method. 2026: Suffolk County Board of Elections via Enhanced Voting public results, unofficial, as of 12:24 AM ET, Nov 4, 2026; governor 1,067 of 1,070 Suffolk EDs reporting; absentee/affidavit ballots may still change small counts. Candidate totals include every party line (Hochul = Dem + WFP; Blakeman = Rep + Con + other lines). 2022: Ben Rosenblatt / OpenElections ED-level file, verified to Suffolk BOE county totals. Precincts matched to geography using Suffolk County GIS Election District polygons and census-land ED shapes: Islip ED 8 and Brookhaven ED 57 contain only barrier-island land; Brookhaven ED 14 combines the eastern barrier beach (Davis Park, Watch Hill) with part of mainland Patchogue, so it is shown separately and left out of the headline; Brookhaven ED 204’s voters live on the mainland (Mastic Beach area) — its Smith Point beach strip has no residents — so it is excluded. Map & analysis: Rae Arora · Who Runs NY.
